Volume
2 Issue 5The
Human Rights MagazineDecember-January 2004
Combat Law
offers you the latest on human rights issues in India. Subscribe to
the magazine to access the complete website and receive regular updates.
CombatLaw.org is a subscribers-only site; you have
to log in to view complete contents. Non-subscribers, or registered
users who have not logged in, will be able to see only summaries of
articles, and the full contents of two articles per issue, indicated
with a 'Full Access ' icon.
Tribal
Forest Interface - Logic of Survival Pradip Prabhu The Inspector General of Forests, in a letter to the
Chief Secretaries of the state governments ordered the summary eviction
of all encroachments. The important challenge before the nation today, is
to find a way in which both the forest and its people can survive with dignity.
Questions
About A Road Pankaj Sekhsaria Road development today is considered a completely acceptable
and all-pervading proposition. The Andaman Trunk Road, however, threatens
the autonomy, culture, privacy and freedom of the Jarawa indigenous community.
Unequal
Access to Justice Brian Lobo Experiences and lessons of seeking justice in the courts
on behalf of tribal communities and individuals in general, and regarding
mass displacement in particular.
Lessons from Mutanga C R Bijoy Injustice in God's Own Country: The Adivasi uprising
in Kerala. Police brutality against adivasis asserting their rights. The
article highlights how parliamentary democracy and the political system
have failed to uphold the constitutional rights of Adivasis.
Driven To Bondage And Starvation Shiraz Bulsara & Priyadarshini Sreenivsa Adivasi migrant labour - a disaggregate and unprotected
workforce. It is this cheap labour that has been subsidizing India's march
to modernization, whose availability is ensured through an annual cycle
of starvation and bondage.
Customary
Law Truimphs In South Africa Alok Gupta The Constitutional Court of South Africa in 2003,
in a historic judgement, ruled that the indigenous people of the Richtersveld
community had both communal land ownership and mineral rights over their
territory, thus bringing customary law on par with common law.
PESA' and the Illusions of Tribal Self Governance Pradip Prabhu The Panchayats (Extension to the Scheduled
Areas) Act 1996 (PESA) upholds participatory democracy at the level of
the gram Sabhas, but state lawmakers are unwilling to ratify it, arguing
that the people are not capable of governing themselves.
Jharkhand
Government Usurping Tribal Land K. Balchand Land that rightfully belongs to the tribals of the Pachwara
panchayat of Amarapara block is being usurped by the government and two
private companies for coal mining.
Judgements On
Arresting Women Rohan Menon The recent Supreme Court judgment overturning the
decision of the Bombay High Court in the Christian Community Welfare Council
petition on what the police must and must not do while arresting women
raises many fears and doubts.
Women A
Rape Victim Speaks Anjana Mishra The survivor of a heinous rape describes her horrifying
ordeal, and speaks out on her long struggle against the perpetrators in
the face of state complicity in perverting justice.
Labour Workers'
Suicides and Their Perpetrators Report of the joint fact finding committee into the
deaths of Anant Dalvi and Akhtar Khan, two workers of the Tata Electric
Companies' project in Trombay.
Children
An Ideal Law: But Only on Paper? Pratibha Menon A critique of the Goa Children's Act, 2003. The Goa
Children's Act,
2003, is the first comprehensive Act that takes into account not just the
welfare & best interests of the child but also the rights of the child
as per the UN 'Convention on the Rights of the Child'. However, the good
intentions behind the act are nullified by the hastily laid out plan of
action.
Judiciary
& Polity Intimidated
Witnesses and Victims: Treated with Hostility Saumya Uma In August 2003, the Union Cabinet cleared an amendment
bill that prescribed stringent punishment for witnesses who turn hostile,
turning a blind eye to the fact that witnesses and victims face serious
threats and harassment.
Judiciary:
A P Chapter K G Kannabiran While judges may disagree amongst themselves,
these disagreements should not be made public, as this compromises the exercise
of their power.
Environment
Dealing with Sand Mafia in UP Tirtho Banerjee Even though the Uttar Pradesh government has launched
a Rs 300 crore project to bring the Ganga back to its original course
along the ghats of Kanpur, indiscriminate mining of sand on the five-kilometre
stretch in the Jajmau area is causing the river to go further away from
the shores.
Education A
Meaningless Bill on School Education Ashok Agarwal The Draft Free
and Compulsory Education for Children Bill, 2003, is certainly not aimed
at giving quality education to poor children.
Race The
Other Face of America Anannya Bhattacharjee Blacks, coloured people and immigrants not
only get a raw deal in American society but also find themselves victimised
by the official administration and judicial system.